Skip to main content
Author photo

Written by Kayla Jane Barrie Updated on Feb 24, 2025 4 mins read

Blog Insurance Surcharges for High Theft Vehicles

Some insurers add up to $1,500 surcharge on vehicles targeted for theft

Insurers and government officials are still looking at new ways to combat vehicle theft. One of these proposals includes vehicle surcharges and driver’s licence suspensions if you are convicted of motor vehicle theft.

The Insurance Bureau of Canada reports that auto theft-related claims in Ontario have surged by 329% from 2018 to 2022. This topic has been gaining traction on our website, along with the most stolen vehicles in Canada and the top anti-theft devices.

Find out how much the vehicle surcharge can be and what to do if your vehicle is on the list.

Summary of insurance surcharges for high theft vehicles

  • Insurance surcharges are nothing new. They began rolling out in 2023. Drivers are seeing an increase in their car insurance in Ontario due to theft.
  • Vehicles with a higher chance of being stolen will see higher rates and a surcharge up to $1,500.
  • See if a vehicle is subject to an insurance surcharge prior to purchase/lease.

What is the car insurance surcharge in Ontario?

Most policies will cover you if your vehicle is stolen. But due to the increased risk of theft of certain vehicles, insurers have added a surcharge on the most targeted vehicles to combat the increasing claims costs related to car theft.

Some insurers have decided to increase the High Theft Risk Premium Surcharge from $500 to $1,500 for new business and renewals starting June 30, 2024, as the auto theft crisis continues to evolve.

Insurance companies are adding a $500 surcharge to policies of commonly stolen cars in Ontario

When customers buy a vehicle that is at a high risk of theft or currently own one, their Ontario auto insurance premiums could significantly increase. You could see increases from $500 to $2,500 per year. You could also see a surcharge of up to $1,500 added to your premium. However, this surcharge can be waived by installing an insurance-recognized theft prevention system, such as Tag.

Additional costs and approved devices will vary based on your insurer. Speak to our brokers if you have a surcharge applied to your premiums.

Are insurers applying a surcharge to all vehicles?

Not all vehicles are impacted or considered high risk for theft. Insurers are focused on vehicles that have seen an increase in the number of occurrences of theft claims. Rather than raising rates across the board, insurers are limiting this surcharge to the specific vehicles identified. Here is a look at what some providers are doing, according to Insurance Business Mag:

Insurance Company Surcharge
CAA A surcharge of $1,500 unless car owners take recommended actions
Aviva $500 surcharge on high-target cars if a TAG or KYCS system (not subsidized) is not installed
Pafco $1,500 surcharge that can be removed by having a TAG system (subsidized)
Economical/Definity $500 surcharge if policyholders opt out; TAG system free or subsidized
Chubb $500 surcharge, with TAG systems either free or subsidized depending on the vehicle

Vehicles with theft surcharge applied

Here is a look at some of the most common vehicles where the surcharge is applied. This list includes vehicles that are manufactured after 2020:

Vehicles With The Insurance Surcharge Applied
Chevrolet Suburban
Chevrolet Tahoe
GMC Yukon
Land Rover, Defender
Lexus GX460
Lexus RX450
Toyota 4Runner
Any other vehicle with an MSRP of $125,000 or greater (regardless of make or model, excluding Electric Vehicles)
Acura, RDX
Dodge, RAM 1500
Jeep, Wrangler
Land Rover, Range Rover (including Sport, Evoque & Velar)
Lexus, RX350
Toyota, Highlander (including Grand Highlander)
Honda, CR-V
Jeep, Grand Cherokee

How does the surcharge impact commercial vehicle policies?

If you are a business owner, you may be wondering how this change will impact your commercial fleet insurance. Depending on your provider, you may have the following options:

  • New business on an identified high-risk vehicle, the surcharge will apply.
  • If the insured elects to do so, they may have Tag installed at a discount. Once the installation is complete, the policy will be updated automatically removing surcharge and discount applied.
  • Premium surcharge of $500 will be applied effectively for new business and renewals.

Speak with your coverage provider to learn more about their surcharge rules and options to lower, or waive, fees.

How to remove a car theft surcharge

Some companies have different approved ways to remove the surcharge. Here is an example of what it could look like:

  • Option 1: The surcharge of $1,500 for eligible after-market engine immobilizers will be fully removed.
  • Option 2: If other eligible preventative anti-theft devices are installed, the surcharge will be reduced by 50% ($750).
  • Option 3: The surcharge can be reduced by $500 by using eligible preventative accessories.
  • No action taken: This will result in the full surcharge of $1,500 being applied.

Be sure to contact your car insurance provider to learn more about their requirements.

You have insurance options. Shop around and save!

Theft prevention is important. So is comparing car insurance quotes to lower your rate and protect your vehicle. Stop online now.

Red car driving on country road

Insurance surcharge for vehicles FAQs

Depending on your insurer, you’ll expect to pay between $500 and $1,500 for the surcharge.

Adding an approved anti-theft device can lower the surcharge. Each provider will have different approved methods, so always check beforehand.

The surge in theft activity has led to a significant increase in claims costs for insurance companies. Since insurance operates on a pooled risk model, these rising costs inevitably result in higher premiums for all policyholders.

To mitigate the impact of theft claims, insurers are implementing surcharges on specific vehicles that have a higher frequency of theft claims and lack preventative measures or the Tag system. This surcharge aims to incentivize vehicle owners to install anti-theft devices or participate in tracking programs, reducing the likelihood of theft and ultimately lowering costs for all.

Prevention is the first step to limiting theft and surcharges

If you add or substitute a vehicle to your policy that is on your insurance company's high-theft list, a high theft surcharge will be added. This surcharge will continue until you decide to add an approved prevention device.

If you are worried that the vehicle you choose is on your insurance company's high theft list, please contact our brokers. They can discuss the premium and your options with you.

Share

Kayla Jane Barrie

Digital Content Writer

Kayla-Jane has been a content writer with ThinkInsure since 2020. She creates insurance content for auto, home, and commercial. Kayla-Jane has a diploma in Journalism.


Insurance Blog And News

Read our insurance blog to get helpful tips, information and news.

illustration of a car with odometer
2025-06-22

Pay-As-You-Go Insurance In Canada

Learn about pay-as-you-go insurance in Canada. Find out the costs, how it works, who it’s for and if it is available in your area.

damaged black and grey cars parked beside each other
2025-06-18

Here's How An At-fault Accident Can Impact Your Insurance

Did you get into an at-fault car accident in Ontario? Learn about at-fault accidents, how insurance companies determine fault, and how it can impact your automobile coverage.

vehicles lined up for sale at a car dealership
2025-06-17

Cheapest Cars To Insure In Ontario

What are the cheapest cars to insure in Ontario? Find out what new and used cars, SUVs, & trucks are the cheapest to insure so you can save.

Asian woman looking at damage from a car accident on a grey car
2025-06-13

Types Of At-fault Accidents In Ontario

What factors determine who is at-fault in an accident in Ontario? Get your questions about what defines at-fault and how to prevent being at-fault for an accident.