Skip to main content
Author photo

Written by Kayla Jane Barrie Apr 22, 2026 6 mins read

Blog Comprehensive Insurance in Ontario

What is comprehensive insurance?

Comprehensive insurance provides additional protection not included in basic automobile policies - it goes above and beyond the minimum requirements. It gives assurance against non-collision related threats, such as vandalism or you need to submit a claim for your car being stolen.

Comprehensive coverage does not cover medical expenses, legal fees, or lost income from an accident. While other accident benefits are becoming optional, comprehensive remains a critical peril-based add-on for total vehicle protection.

For example, if your vehicle was stolen, then later found and returned to you, you could submit a car insurance claim to cover the cost of repairs.

What you need to know about comprehensive car insurance coverage

  • Comprehensive insurance is an optional, non-mandatory car insurance add-on in Ontario.
  • It costs between $150-200 yearly to add comprehensive to your policy.
  • It protects the vehicle from non-collision events such as theft, natural disasters, animals, falling trees, and vandalism.
  • It doesn't include injuries to third parties or damage to other vehicles. This is covered by collision and liability coverage.
  • Purchasing comprehensive coverage may not be cost-effective for an older vehicle that has depreciated significantly.

Is comprehensive insurance mandatory?

Comprehensive insurance provides additional protection not included in basic automobile policies - it goes above and beyond the minimum requirements. It gives assurance against non-collision related threats, such as vandalism or you need to submit a claim for your car being stolen.

It’s similar to all perils or specified perils and optional policy endorsements (OPCFs). It’s extra protection added to your basic coverage.

In some cases, such as if you lease your vehicle, the lender might require you to have full coverage.

Boost your protection with comprehensive coverage

Hit the road with peace of mind knowing that you are covered. Speak with our team of professional brokers to compare rates for comprehensive insurance coverage.

red car driving through a road with trees on the sides

Is comprehensive insurance the same as full coverage?

Full automobile insurance is something people refer to when they have all types of coverage. This means you have comprehensive, collision, and other optional policies.

If you ask for just comprehensive, you might find yourself unprotected if you are at fault in a standard fender-bender, as collision coverage covers that.

Even full coverage doesn't cover everything. Things like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, and gap insurance are usually extra add-ons.

What does comprehensive insurance cover

One of the most important aspects of comprehensive coverage, is understanding what it can cover.

“This coverage pays for losses, other than those covered by collision or upset, including perils or dangers listed under Specified Perils, falling or flying objects, missiles and vandalism,” says FSCO.

Here is what it includes:

What does comprehensive insurance not cover?

Comprehensive coverage does not cover medical expenses, legal fees, or lost income from an accident. Here is a look at what items are excluded from comprehensive coverage.

  • Medical expenses or loss of income after an accident.
  • Damage to another driver’s vehicle as a result of an accident.
  • Medical expenses or lost income for another person after an accident.
  • Theft by a member of your household.
  • Rental car accident after filing a claim.
  • Personal items stolen from your car.

Should you have comprehensive car insurance?

When comparing options, it’s important to determine whether comprehensive meets your needs. Some people opt not to have it to keep payment costs down.

However, you are also reducing your amount of protection. Depending on the cause of the damage, you may be on the hook for the repairs. Note that you may need to have it if you have a loan on the vehicle.

Consider these important questions when determining your needs:

  • Peace of mind: Is the extra amount added to your premium worth the peace of mind?
  • Financial situation: Are you able to pay out of pocket for repairs if you choose against it?
  • Vehicle value: Many owners of older vehicles don't add this type of because of the lower vehicle value.
  • Risk: Do you think there is a risk or chance that you will need to make a claim?
  • Car loan: Do you have a car loan? If so, your lender will likely want you to have comprehensive insurance.

Expect comprehensive protection to add a few hundred dollars to your Ontario car insurance quote.

examples of what comprehensive car coverage includes

How does comprehensive insurance work?

In Ontario, you can add comprehensive insurance to your auto insurance policy. This coverage provides financial protection for damages to your vehicle that are not caused by a collision.

Comprehensive insurance example

Let's say you park your car on the street overnight, and a severe storm hits the area. Comprehensive insurance will cover the repair costs if a large tree limb falls on your car, causing significant damage to the roof and windshield.

Without comprehensive insurance: You'd pay out of pocket for car damage, which can cost thousands, depending on the extent.

With comprehensive insurance: If you have comprehensive coverage, file a claim with your insurance company. Once they assess the damage, they'll cover the cost of repairs minus your deductible.

The terms and conditions of comprehensive coverage may vary depending on the insurance provider and your policy details. In this example, having comprehensive insurance would save you from paying for the repairs yourself as long as your policy covers the damage.

How does comprehensive insurance work for claims?

A comprehensive insurance claim is similar to a standard auto insurance claim. The only difference is what you are claiming and your deductible amount.

Most policies include a $300 or $500 deductible. You can increase your amount, which will help lower the cost. You only need to pay your deductible for claims under comprehensive coverage.

Here’s a scenario to consider: You are driving, and a stone flies up on the 401 and cracks your windshield, requiring a full replacement equipped with sensor recalibration for $1,200. With a $300 deductible in place, you pay your portion, and your insurer picks up the $900 balance.

Do you need collision and comprehensive insurance?

Comprehensive policies cover more sources of damage to your vehicle than collision insurance.

If you have an older vehicle, then collision may not be in your best interests. You may want something else if you want to pay as little as possible. It all comes down to your risk tolerance and ability to cover costs if you experience damage.

For many drivers, having both types provides them with peace of mind. You’ll have financial protection against most threats to your vehicle.

Is comprehensive coverage worth it?

Whether or not comprehensive insurance is worth it depends on your specific situation. You may be willing to pay a little extra for peace of mind. Some people want lower monthly payments.

If you are considering the benefit of comprehensive coverage, ask yourself these three questions:

  • Is your car worth less than $5,000? Consider dropping it./li>
  • Is your car financed/leased? Mandatory./li>
  • Do you park on the street in Toronto? Highly recommended.

If you have questions about adding additional coverage options to your policy, our car insurance brokers are ready to assist you.

Comprehensive insurance FAQs

It depends - coverage limits, car value, age, and other factors affect costs. Expect to pay a few hundred dollars extra to add comprehensive coverage. Find out how your policy will cost by contacting us today.

If you lease or finance your vehicle, you will most likely need comprehensive coverage, which will be part of your lease or finance agreement.

No. Insurance for a rental car is available by adding policy endorsement OPCF 20.

Comprehensive may cover you for damage to your vehicle from rodents and animals. Check your policy and speak with your insurer to confirm.

Comprehensive is subject to a coverage limit (the most your policy will pay out). This amount is different depending on your policy options and insurer. Claims made are subject to these limits.

To know if your insurance covers someone else driving your car, it depends on your insurance. It’s important to check with your insurer to get clarification. Many companies now offer driving other cars (DOC), or occasional driver coverage, under a full comprehensive policy.

Comprehensive and third party liability are different types of policies, but it is recommended to have both. Third party coverage is mandatory - it covers you if you are at-fault for an accident that results in damage or injury. Comprehensive is an optional addition.

Many people consider dropping the comprehensive as their car ages. It’s a quick way to save money on your plan. Vehicles depreciate at different rates, so it depends on your current situation.

Consider the value of your car against your policy costs and financial situation. Speak with your insurer to learn about your options.

Compare the best rates for comprehensive insurance

Find out if your auto insurance has comprehensive coverage by checking your policy. If you do, your policy documents will outline the limits, deductible, and other key information. If you aren’t sure, you can contact us to learn more.

Share

Kayla Jane Barrie

Digital Content Writer

Kayla-Jane has been a content writer with ThinkInsure since 2020. She creates insurance content for auto, home, and commercial. Kayla-Jane has a diploma in Journalism.


Insurance Blog And News

Read our insurance blog to get helpful tips, information and news.

car with tree branch fallen on it
2026-04-22

Comprehensive Insurance in Ontario

Learn about Comprehensive Insurance in Ontario. We’ll explain comprehensive insurance policies, how much it costs and when you need it. Get answers to common questions about this type of car insurance.

black car damaged from collision
2026-04-15

Collision Insurance in Ontario Explained

We’ll explain collision car insurance in Ontario. Learn about the coverage, if you need collision insurance for older vehicles, how much it will cost, and get answers to common questions.

Rural road with many potholes filled with water
2026-03-09

Is Pothole Damage To My Vehicle Covered By Insurance?

Has your vehicle been damaged by hitting a pothole? Find out if your insurance will cover the damage. Learn about tips to avoid potholes.

red car parked behind shrubs
2026-02-25

Accident Benefits Are Changing in Ontario

Big changes are coming to Ontario car insurance. Starting July 1, 2026, many accident benefits will become optional. Learn how these "à la carte" reforms impact your coverage and why opting out could be a major financial risk.