Barrie Insurance Broker

1-855-550-5515

Save more with Barrie's best auto insurance broker. Get the coverage you need and save up to $983* annually.

Compare rates from Canada's top insurance providers

See all providers

Written by Nolan Wilson Updated on September 11, 2025 min read

Looking for a top-rated insurance broker in Barrie?

Using an insurance broker is the best way to shop for insurance in Barrie. Brokers represent you and offer the most insurance options. They compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best coverage at the lowest rates.

ThinkInsure is a top-rated 4.7-star insurance broker. We help Barrie residents with all their coverage needs—home, car, business, life, travel, and more. Start a quote online or give us a call to find out why we’re a leading broker in Barrie. We look forward to helping you save money on your next policy.

Top takeaways about using a Barrie insurance broker

Save up to $983 on your auto insurance policy when you compare your options with a broker.
Get auto insurance rates starting at $1,165 and home insurance starting at $555.
Brokers can address all your insurance requirements - home, auto, business, and more.
You’ll get expert advice from a licensed insurance broker who puts your best interests first.

See our 5 star insurance broker reviews

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars in 1530 Google reviews

Our brokers help customers in Barrie and all over Ontario get insured for a lower rate.

See all reviews

Raghav Gupta

2025-08-11

I am pretty happy with their services. This my second year through them and I came across an agent Anuraag Jassal Web Customer Service Broker He is the best advisor I ever talked to in my last 7 years of experience. He reviewed my policies and helped me correct some errors which has decreased my premium to almost half. He helped me understand how to read our policy correctly and went over different clauses in detail while deciding on buying a new car etc. I wish there was a way to go and personally meet him as I am going through a rough patch and all the help he has given me in the last month on multiple matters is just amazing. He is actually doing his job and seems like he loves it. Thanks Anuraag Jassal.

Pina Battaglia

2025-08-06

Sohel was amazing. Made the initial process quick and seamless. Very knowledgeable, courteous and friendly.

Ma emma Bergonio

2025-08-05

Sohel is very helpful when it comes to finding the best rate and coverage.

Galit Moroz

2025-08-02

I highly recommend Todd as an insurance broker! He was incredibly helpful, always quick to respond to my questions, and ensured I found the best car insurance to fit my needs. His expertise made the process smooth and stress-free.

preeya mistry

2025-07-31

Had the pleasure of working with Dylan. He goes above and beyond. He is so non-judgmental and super helpful. I highly recommend requesting his help when inquiring.

Mason Khoury

2025-07-27

Dealt with Dylan S, who was able to secure me a phenomenal insurance quote within 48 hours of my renewal deadline (current policy was through ThinkInsure). This lad is amazing at what he does, no other way to put it! I have been dealing with ThinkInsure since I was a student in post secondary & they’ve always done their best to make sure I had an affordable policy. If you want an insurance broker who actually goes the “extra mile” & doesn’t simply brush you off as another sales lead, I’d look no further. They’ve got my business for the foreseeable future 🤘🏻

Zack Rowe

2025-07-20

Dylan was great and able to get me on the road

Tala Redrose

2025-07-17

I recently dealt with Sohel Rahman for my car insurance. I highly recommend him. I appreciated his professionalism and his patient. My situation was difficult but he was truly dedicated to finding me the fastest and best possible vehicle's coverage. Natalia

How to compare quotes with a Barrie car insurance broker

We'll help you find quotes from top insurers in minutes!

1) Begin your quote

Enter some personal info to get started.

2) Enter your driving and car information

Enter your driving details and then select your vehicle.

3) Compare multiple quotes

See rates from the top companies.

Choose the lowest rate

Choose your rate and get insured.

Get Started

How do Barrie insurance brokers work?

father standing with hand on hip near car and looking at son

An insurance broker is different than other insurance professionals in Barrie. Their primary role is to represent and assist you with your insurance search. Brokers collect your information and compare quotes from multiple insurance providers. This allows them to find you the best rates and coverage based on your unique needs. Brokers also provide customer service. They are your go-to for questions, policy changes, quotes, and claims support.

How can a broker help you save on insurance in Barrie?

Insurance brokers provide you with the best opportunity to save. There are many things they can help you with to lower your premiums:

Combine insurance policies: A home and auto insurance bundle allows you to save on both. The more insurance you bundle, the more you can save.
Insurance discounts: Brokers will help you uncover all available insurance discounts for which you could qualify.
Specialized insurance products: Some people require more specific types of coverage. A broker can help you get the coverage you need.
Policy recommendation: Get recommendations from brokers based on your unique situation and the information you provide them during the quote process.

How is an insurance broker in Barrie different than an insurance agent?

Even though insurance brokers and agents offer insurance to consumers, there are some stark differences. You can access coverage and rates from many top insurance companies with a broker. An insurance agent can only offer you insurance from the company they represent. Brokers have your best interests in mind and advocate on your behalf. So, if you need to change your policy, have questions about coverage, or need to file a claim, they are here to help. Agents, on the other hand, operate in the best interest of the company they represent.

How much does a Barrie insurance broker cost to use?

Working with an insurance broker in Barrie (or anywhere else) costs nothing. Brokers do not charge you for their services. Their insurance partners pay them. So, you have nothing to lose and a lot to gain by using a broker to compare quotes.

Get more affordable premiums with a Barrie car insurance broker

Our insurance brokers in Barrie can help you get the right policy to meet your driving needs. Whether you have a long commute, barely drive, or anything in between, we’ll help you find the lowest car insurance in Barrie. Drivers can save up to $983 per year or $82 monthly. Quotes start as low as $1,165 per year.

And it doesn't matter what you drive, either. We can get quotes for cars, SUVs, trucks, and electric vehicles. Have a business or drive for Uber. We can get you coverage no matter what you drive.

There is no doubt that pickups are popular in Barrie. We’ll make sure you have the best pickup truck insurance

Time to renew? Want to explore your options? Get an auto insurance quote today!

Work with a trusted home insurance broker in Barrie

Buying a home in Barrie can be expensive. Housing costs rival other similar areas in the GTA. According to Zolo.ca Barrie real estate trends, the average house price is about $695,254 (As of July 2025).

So, you’ll want to protect your investment with proper home insurance. Our brokers will find you a policy that will protect your property and allow you to sleep well at night, knowing you’re covered.

Not a homeowner? No problem! Our brokers have all your needs covered, regardless of your living situation. We can get you:

Condo insurance for your unit
Tenant insurance if you’re renting an apartment or townhome
Landlord insurance if you lease out a rental property

We have all your home insurance needs covered. Start a quote online or give us a call.

Brokers offer insurance in Barrie for all lifestyles

Everyone has unique insurance needs. We live different lifestyles, so we need different types of insurance protection. In Barrie, outdoor living is popular. If you enjoy hitting the open water on your vessel, you’ll need boat insurance. Do you love to rip up the trails on your ATV? Do you need ATV insurance? Enjoy camping? We can ensure you have the right RV insurance. See what we're getting at here? We have all the insurance products to ensure you're protected.

Why choose ThinkInsure to be your Barrie insurance broker?

Our licensed insurance brokers have been helping customers for over 50 years with all their insurance needs. We'll ensure you get proper coverage at a great price. Here are some reasons to use a ThinkInsure broker:

senior couple with their dog together at home

Expert unbiased advice: Expect honest and unbiased advice. We are not affiliated with any insurance companies.
Lower premiums: Save up to 30% with us. We’ll find you more affordable premiums and discounts.
We’re fully licensed brokers: We are members of the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) and the Insurance Brokers Association of Ontario (IBAO).
We’re partners with top insurers: We have partnerships with over 50 of the top insurance providers in the country for you. Get quotes from CAA Insurance, Aviva, Travelers, Wawanesa, and many more.
Top-rated 4.7 star service: You’ll have a dedicated broker to assist you with all your insurance needs.

Barrie insurance broker FAQs

Is a Barrie car insurance broker worth it?

Considering there is no fee for using an insurance broker in Barre, it’s worth contacting one to see what they can do for you. They do much more than just compare quotes, they provide a lot of value - advice, advocacy, service, and more.

Are Barrie insurance brokers cheaper than insurance companies?

Barrie insurance brokers can find you affordable rates compared to a single insurer. Their ability to scour the market and comparison shop makes it more likely that a broker will find you a better price.

What are the disadvantages of using an insurance broker in Barrie?

There aren't many disadvantages to using an insurance broker in Barrie. But remember, no two brokers are the same. So, choosing the right broker (us!) is the most important decision.

Get a quote with a Barrie insurance broker

Using an insurance broker in Barrie provides you with the best opportunity to save money on your next policy. So, give us a call. Whether your policy is coming up for renewal, you are dissatisfied with your current provider, or you want to explore your options, we can help.

Get Started

Sources

* Based on the difference between the average lowest premium and the overall average premium in Barrie for estimates completed from January 1 to March 20, 2025, for drivers with a clean driving record.

Nolan Wilson

Content Marketing Manager

Nolan is a content marketing manager and writer at ThinkInsure. He has 15+ years of experience in the insurance industry, working with brokerages and direct insurers to create compelling insurance content, specializing in auto, home, and commercial.

Insurance Blog And News

Read our insurance blog to get helpful tips, information and news.

man wearing red jacket smiling while looking outside car window

2025-09-08

Save more with Barrie's best auto insurance broker. Get the coverage you need and save up to $983* annually.

Compare rates from Canada's top insurance providers

Looking for a top-rated insurance broker in Barrie?

Top takeaways about using a Barrie insurance broker

See our 5 star insurance broker reviews