Cheap Car Insurance in Toronto: Best Auto Insurance Quotes

1-855-550-5515

Find the best rates by comparing car insurance quotes in Toronto and save $821* on average.

Compare Toronto car insurance quotes from top providers

See all providers

Written by Nolan Wilson Updated on June 12, 2025 min read

Toronto's best car insurance savings

Are you shopping for car insurance in Toronto? Like other drivers, you are probably tired of paying too much for car insurance rates in 2025. We don’t blame you! We’ll help you save with great rates and get personalized coverage.

Why does car insurance cost so much in Toronto? The GTA has over 7 million residents, lots of traffic, the longest commutes, and the busiest highways in the country. This increases the risk of accidents, auto theft, and fraud, resulting in more expensive car insurance in Toronto. Inflation and economic uncertainty don't help either.

Comparing car insurance quotes is the best way to lower your premiums. Located in Toronto, we are experts in auto insurance in the GTA. Our local advisors help Toronto drivers find the cheapest car insurance rates. We'll compare quotes from the leading car insurance companies and help you get the most affordable rate. Getting the best car insurance quote is quick and easy with ThinkInsure. Get a quote online anytime.

Toronto car insurance key takeaways

The average cost of car insurance in Toronto in 2025 is $2,246.
Toronto's auto insurance premiums are less than the average rate of $2,638 in the GTA and over $200 higher than the provincial average of $2,006.
East Toronto is the most affordable neighbourhood. The average rate in The Beaches and Danforth is $2,158 per year.

How to get cheap Toronto car insurance quotes

Comparing quotes online is easy with ThinkInsure. It's also the best way to save!

1) Start your quote

Tell us a bit about yourself to get started.

2) Enter your vehicle and driving information

Tell us about your car and driving habits.

3) Compare the cheapest quotes

See quotes from top insurance companies in Canada.

Choose your policy

Choose the lowest rate. Confirm the details with our experts and buy your insurance.

Get Quotes

Car insurance in Toronto and how it works

Cars are waiting for a traffic signal around Flatiron Building in downtown Toronto

Each province sets car insurance rules. In Ontario, these rules are in Ontario’s Insurance Act. Toronto follows the same rules as all other cities in the province. Here are the basics:

Mandatory insurance: All drivers require car insurance. You cannot drive without it. If caught driving without insurance, you face a licence suspension and fines of up to $50,000.
Licensing: You must be a resident and have a valid Ontario drivers licence.
Minimum requirements: You must have a minimum amount of insurance. This includes third-party liability, statutory accident benefits, and uninsured automobile coverage. You can add extra insurance for collision, comprehensive, and more.
Private insurance: Policies are issued through private insurance companies. You can get coverage through a broker, insurance agent, or direct writer.
No fault: No fault insurance applies. You deal with your insurance provider.

Who regulates car insurance in Toronto?

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRAO) is an independent regulatory agency that oversees car insurance in Ontario.

It’s part of the Ontario Ministry of Finance. They oversee close to 300 insurance providers in the province.

What is the minimum amount of car insurance required in Toronto?

All drivers must have at least $200,000 in third-party liability. While this is the minimum, the vast majority of drivers have significantly higher limits. This protects them if something bad happens, like an accident, fraud, crime, theft, or other covered dangers. This is especially true in highly populated regions, where collisions are more common. Most have at least $1 million in liability because of rising costs.

Recent Toronto auto insurance quotes

2025/06/15

Auto insurance quote in TORONTO, ON
Vehicle: MERCEDES-BENZ EQE350 4MATIC 4DR 2023
CAA My Pace	$1,069
SGI Canada	$2,425
CAA Connect	$2,992
Intact	$3,060
Savings from top 4 cheapest quotes	$1,991

2025/06/14

Auto insurance quote in TORONTO, ON
Vehicle: NISSAN ROGUE SV 4DR AWD 2017
CAA My Pace	$852
Pembridge	$2,079
Aviva	$2,417
Wawanesa	$2,527
Savings from top 4 cheapest quotes	$1,675

2025/06/13

Auto insurance quote in TORONTO, ON
Vehicle: TOYOTA CAMRY XLE HEV 4DR 2019
Aviva Journey	$1,656
Aviva	$1,841
Pembridge	$2,309
Travelers	$2,517
Savings from top 4 cheapest quotes	$861

2025/06/12

Auto insurance quote in TORONTO, ON
Vehicle: TOYOTA COROLLA CE 4DR 2005
Pembridge	$2,393
Intact	$3,333
Wawanesa	$3,402
CAA My Pace	$3,678
Savings from top 4 cheapest quotes	$1,285

5 star reviews for car insurance in Toronto

Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars in 1507 Google reviews

We help thousands of customers save on their auto insurance.

See all reviews

Carla Keown

2025-05-04

Besty was incredibly kind and helpful during a stressful time. I had no idea that a handheld ticket would result in my insurance company dropping me. It was a year after the ticket that I was informed of this so I was shocked and stressed. Besty assured me that we had time to figure out a solution and she worked around my busy schedule to find me the best insurance products to suit my situation. Besty is a 10/10 recommend!!!

e t

2025-05-01

I cannot say enough great things about Todd A! From start to finish, he provided an exceptional customer experience that truly stood out. Not only was he incredibly knowledgeable and efficient, but his kindness and cheerful attitude made the process smooth and absolutely stress-free. What could have been overwhelming was instead seamless and easy, thanks to his reassuring guidance and expertise. He was always quick to respond, informative, and genuinely invested in ensuring I got the best coverage for my needs—all while making sure I felt comfortable and confident every step of the way. His level of professionalism and warmth turned what could have been a daunting task into an absolute pleasure. If you're looking for someone who goes above and beyond to provide top-tier customer service, look no further than Todd A at ThinkInsure. Thank you for making this experience effortless and enjoyable, you made this all happen for me!

Carl Cronkhite

2025-04-24

I highly recommend ThinkInsure when looking for Insurance, Betsy Bannon was a huge help! As a high risk driver it was very difficult to find a premium i could afford and only had a few weeks to do so. I contacted ThinkInsure and Betsy was able to explain everything and find me a great policy right away. Thank you Betsy!

Keira Busby

2025-04-17

very friendly and willing to help anyway they can! great experience all way round.

Dharma Buyse

2025-04-17

Betsy Bannon was so helpful! I was insuring my new truck with my first personal policy and after one broker went mia on my calls she picked up, although from commercial department, and still handled everything for me within 24 hours! Also she pointed out that previously the drivers history was forgotten about in the prior list of documents that was requested from me. Definitely knows exactly what she’s doing and works great winging it in a different department than her specialty! I’m a high risk driver for one more year, unfortunately (did not follow cops advisory to fight distracted ticket while checking directions at a red) but she found the best quote for me, and revised this last minuite to find one that further accepted my 8year claim free policy on a commercial registered insurance. She was friendly, prompt to reply, patient, personable, and very knowledgeable. Finding insurance with one more year of this record has been discouraging as a now overly cautious driver, but she made it as seamless as possible

Quentin Chiotti

2025-04-16

Fast, seamless, and efficient. Betsy Bannon was great to work with. Thanks ThinkInsure.

Csaba Deac

2025-04-11

Special Thanks to Betsy Bannon. If you need business insurance , highly recommend her

Kelly Bouchard

2025-04-10

Sohel is amazing!! He responded so quickly and went out of his way to accommodate me. There were a few things I didn’t quite understand and he took the time to explain and reassure me that everything was properly covered. His follow up is so good! I highly recommend his service and expertise. He does all the research and comparisons for you to save you a lot of money! I can’t believe how much I was overpaying with my long time providers. Thanks Sohel!!

Mandatory car insurance in Toronto

You must have a minimum amount of mandatory auto insurance to drive. There are four main types of coverage included in your policy:

Third-party liability (TPL): Covers liability claims against you from an at-fault accident. Basic plans have $200,000 in TPL. Most have $1 million or more in coverage. Insurers typically offer you several coverage limit options.
Direct compensation property damage (DCPD): DCPD covers damage for accidents when you are not at fault. It also covers loss of use. For example, if you are waiting at a light and get rear-ended by another motorist. This is part of the no-fault system. As of January 1, 2024, drivers will have the ability to opt out of this coverage using OPCF 49.
Accident benefits: Accident benefits cover the driver and passengers if injured. It also applies to pedestrians and cyclists. Statutory accident benefits coverage ensures you receive medical care. It covers costs that are above what OHIP supplies. It also helps with attendant care, rehabilitation, and lost income costs. Limits apply and can be increased.
Uninsured motorist: This is also known as uninsured automobile coverage. It covers you if you are injured by an uninsured driver or in a hit-and-run. Standard coverage is $200,000, but this amount can be increased.

Optional auto insurance in Toronto

There is also additional protection you can add to your auto insurance policy. The most common options people add are collision, comprehensive, and specified or all perils. With the heightened threats of such a busy city (accidents, fraud, theft), most people get extra protection to ensure they're covered. Here are the most common types of additional coverage you can get:

Collision coverage: This one is pretty straightforward. You have protection if you are involved in an accident with another vehicle or an object (e.g., a tree, street sign, or light post).
Comprehensive coverage: This protects you from loss or damage from non-driving events. Coverage includes theft, vandalism, falling objects, and damage from the weather (wind, hail, flooding).
All perils: This combines collision and comprehensive. You have protection for all perils unless they are expressly excluded.
Specified perils: Your policy protects all the perils listed. Anything listed is covered. This is more affordable than comprehensive while still providing most of the protection.
Emergency roadside assistance: Get roadside assistance when you need it. Many insurers offer this as part of their policy or as an add-on. Some services include towing, battery boost, flat tire, and more.

ThinkInsure Tip : Add OPCF to your policy if you are insuring a new vehicle

Did you know a new car can depreciate by 20-30% in the first year alone? If your car is totalled or stolen, standard insurance only covers the depreciated value, which may not be enough to pay off your loan. OPCF 43 waives depreciation for the first few years, ensuring you receive a payout that reflects the original or replacement value of your car.

Customize your Toronto automobile policy with optional insurance endorsements

You can personalize your plan even more by adding insurance endorsements. You can add one or multiple, depending on your preference.

Adding an endorsement will slightly increase your premiums and provide additional protection. Some of the types of coverage you can add to your policy include:

Agreed value of automobiles (OPCF 19A): Insurers agree to pay a specific amount if your vehicle is a total loss.
Transportation replacement: Covers rental car insurance and transportation if your vehicle was stolen or while getting repaired.
Rental car coverage (OPCF 27): Coverage for when you drive vehicles that are not your own, such as a rental car.
Accident forgiveness (OPCF 39): Protects your driving record after your first at-fault accident.
Waiver of depreciation (OPCF 43): Insurers cannot deduct depreciation from your vehicle's value when making a claim.
Family protection (OPCF 44R): Covers you or your family if you are injured, even if you’re not in the car when the accident happens.

What is the average cost of car insurance in Toronto?

Toronto has some of the highest car insurance rates in the province. According to our 2025 customer car insurance quote data, the average rate is $2,246 in Toronto, which is just over $200 higher than the provincial average.

Here’s a Toronto car insurance premium breakdown by different time frames:

Annually: $2,246
Semi-annually: $1,123
Quarterly: $561.50
Monthly: $187.16
Weekly: $43.19
Daily: $6.15

Rates are about $400 less than the GTA's overall average. Based on FSRAO data from October 2024, the average cost of auto insurance in the GTA is $2,638. Where you live in the area can significantly impact how much you pay for insurance, especially in the GTA. A change in city or postal code can make a big difference.

Toronto car insurance rates by year

Car insurance premiums can fluctuate frequently, more so than in recent memory. We sourced quote data from our customers over the past seven years, providing an overview of how premiums can change year by year.

As you can see, premiums are down in 2022 compared to 2019-2020. In 2021, there was a price dip because of pandemic discounts offered by companies. Fewer people were on the road, reducing the number of accidents and claims. In 2023 and 2024, we’ve seen prices start to creep back to pre-pandemic levels. Costs have levelled off in the first quarter of 2025, but auto insurance costs are still higher in Toronto than the provincial average of $2,006. Below, you’ll see how rates have changed year over year:

Year	Average annual premium
2025	$2,246
2024	$2,264
2023	$2,225
2022	$2,103
2021	$2,097
2020	$2,322
2019	$2,282
Average rate (2019-2025)	$2,200

Toronto car insurance rates by driver type

The category you fit into can affect your car insurance rates. Your age, gender, marital status, and driving record are all factors insurers use to assess you as a driver.

We examined our customer quote data to see how different factors impact your costs. Here’s what we found:

Drivers under 25 years old pay $200+ more than the city average.
Being in the high-risk insurance category increases your rates by 272%.
Mature drivers over 50 have the lowest premiums. They pay close to $300 less than the city average.
Men pay more than women. Single people pay more than married couples. But not by a significant margin.
Tickets, accidents, suspensions, and policy cancellations will significantly increase your rate. You could see an increase from 11% to 29% for one infraction.

	Premium	Monthly	Difference
Driver type
All drivers	$2,246	$187
Young drivers (25 and under)	$2,598	$217	15.67%
Middle age (25 - 50)	$2,342	$195	4.27%
Mature/senior drivers (50+)	$1,909	$159	-15.00%
High risk drivers	$8,370	$698	272.66%
Demographics
Male	$2,267	$189	0.93%
Female	$2,194	$183	-2.32%
Married	$2,139	$178	-4.76%
Single	$2,293	$191	2.09%
Driving record
Clean driving record	$2,246	$187
1 ticket within the past 3 years	$2,605	$217	15.98%
1 accident in 3 years	$2,880	$240	28.23%
1 cancellation in 3 years	$2,799	$233	24.62%
1 suspension in 3 years	$2,498	$208	11.22%

***

Multi-car insurance plans save Toronto drivers money

If you own more than one vehicle, including them in the same policy makes sense. This not only makes it easier for you to manage your coverage, you’ll also save on all vehicles. For example, drivers save an average of $350 per vehicle in Toronto if they insure two cars with the same insurer.

	Average rate	Average rate per vehicle	Total savings	Savings per vehicle
1 car	$2,246	$2,246
2 cars	$3,093	$1,547	$699	$350

***

Are car insurance rates in Toronto higher than in other cities?

Toronto has more expensive car insurance rates than most cities in the province. It consistently ranks in the top 10 of the most expensive cities. Premiums cost about 12% more than the provincial average.

The graphic below shows that Mississauga and Brampton have higher premiums. Auto insurance costs in the GTA are much higher than in most cities.

According to data from FSRAO, GTA auto insurance rates are $2,638 on average (As of October 2024). In other urban areas, it is $1,918; in rural areas, it is $1,592. Costs are significantly cheaper in smaller cities throughout the province.

Average Toronto car insurance rate compared to other Ontario cities info graphic

City	Average Rate
Toronto	$2,246
GTA	$2,638
Brampton	$2,890
Mississauga	$2,424
Newmarket	$2,065
Richmond Hill	$2,417
Milton	$2,223
Markham	$2,331
Barrie	$2,148
Oshawa	$2,335
Peterborough	$1,770
Oakville	$1,945
North York	$2,595
Whitby	$1,951
Ajax	$2,399
Pickering	$2,193
Aurora	$2,319
Etobicoke	$2,502

****

What parts of Toronto have the cheapest car insurance?

Location, location, location. Where you live within the city can affect how much you pay for car insurance by hundreds of dollars annually. Insurers assess your postal code and neighbourhood.

We sourced our quote data to see how costs differ by area. Based on our findings, Downtown and East Toronto were the cheapest. The York area is the most expensive. See a breakdown here:

Area in City	Postal Codes	Neighbourhoods	Average Premium
Downtown Toronto	M4W, M4X, M4Y, M5A, M5B, M5C, M5E, M5G, M5H, M5J, M5K, M5L, M5S, M5T, M5V, M5W, M5X, M6G	Rosedale, Cabbagetown, Harbourfront, Regent Park, Kensington Market, Chinatown	$2,195
East Toronto	M4E, M4K, M4L, M4M	The Danforth, The Beaches	$2,158
West Toronto	M6H, M6J, M6K, M6P, M6R, M6S	Dufferin, Dovercourt Village, Little Portugal, Trinity, Parkdale Village, Roncesvalles	$2,296
Central Toronto	M4N, M4P, M4R, M4S, M4T, M4V, M5N, M5P, M5R	Lawrence Park, Davisville, Summerhill, Forest Hill, Deer Park, Roselawn, The Annex, Yorkville	$2,325
Etobicoke	M8V, M8W, M8Y, M8Z, M9A, M9B, M9C, M9L, M9M, M9N, M9P, M9R, M9V, M9W	Mimico, The Kingsway, Rexdale, Martin Grove Gardens	$2,524
Scarborough	M1B, M1C, M1E, M1G, M1H, M1J, M1K, M1L, M1M, M1N, M1P, M1R, M1S, M1T, M1V, M1W, M1X	Port Union, Golden Mile, Cliffside, Scarborough Town Centre, Wexford	$2,564
York	M6C, M6E, M6M, M6N	Cedarvale, Fairbanks, Humewood, The Junction	$2,631
North York	M2H, M2J, M2K, M2L, M2M, M2N, M2P, M2R, M3A, M3B, M3C, M3H, M3J, M3K, M3L, M3M, M3N, M4A, M5M, M6A, M6B, M6L	York Mills, Willowdale, Downsview, Don Mills, Victoria Village, Glencairn	$2,617
East York	M4B, M4C, M4G, M4H, M4J	Parkview Hill, Woodbine Heights, Leaside, Danforth, Thorncliffe Park	$2,494

***

Toronto car insurance rates by vehicle brand and model

The vehicle you choose to drive will play a role in determining your car insurance rates. By how much? We compared customer quotes by vehicle brand and top models. This lets you know how much premiums can change based on your vehicle.

Premiums by brand

Here is a breakdown of the average premiums for the top vehicle brands driven in the city. Subaru and Chevrolet top the list with the lowest rates.

Vehicle brand	Average premium	Monthly payment
All brands	$2,246	$187
Honda	$2,260	$188
Toyota	$2,097	$175
Ford	$2,309	$192
Hyundai	$2,310	$193
Kia	$2,373	$198
GMC	$3,377	$281
Chevrolet	$1,537	$128
RAM	$2,752	$229
Dodge	$2,752	$229
Jeep	$2,637	$220
Subaru	$1,969	$164
Mazda	$2,158	$180
Nissan	$2,164	$180
Volkswagen	$1,968	$164
Mercedes	$2,222	$185
BMW	$2,226	$186
Tesla	$2,765	$230
Audi	$2,300	$192
Lexus	$2,578	$215

***

Premiums by model

We compared some of the most popular models to see how much premiums differ. The table below shows compact car models that cost hundreds of dollars less annually to insure.

Vehicle model	Average premium	Monthly payment
Honda Civic	$2,058	$172
Toyota Corolla	$2,443	$204
Hyundai Elantra	$2,299	$192
Nissan Sentra	$1,493	$124
Tesla Model 3	$2,948	$246
Mazda 3	$2,512	$209
Toyota Prius	$2,174	$181
Ford F 150	$1,910	$159
Toyota RAV4	$2,225	$185
Nissan Rogue	$2,259	$188
Jeep Grand Cherokee	$2,032	$169

Why is Toronto auto insurance so expensive?

Auto insurance in Toronto is expensive compared to other cities in the province. Why is this the case? There are a series of contributing factors:

Canada's largest city: Toronto is far and away the most populated city in the country. According to Stats Can, Toronto CMA passed 7 million in July 2024, and it grew by a record 3.9% in one year.
The busiest highways: Highway 401 is the busiest in North America. There are also 403, 407 (the world's first all-electronic toll road), 427, QEW, and 404 (Don Valley Parkway).
Significant commuter traffic: According to 2021 Census Data, there are over 791,000 daily commuters, and over 425,000 drive.
Auto theft on the rise: The Toronto Police Service reports there were 9,352 auto thefts in 2024 and 12,351 in 2023. There has been a considerable spike in auto thefts post-pandemic. The highest instances of theft were in West Humber-Clairville, Etobicoke, and Milliken.
Thefts from vehicles remain an issue: Data from the Toronto Police Service reports 7,724 vehicle thefts in 2024. While this is down from previous years (2023 - 8,744, 2022 - 9,424), it remains an issue.
High auto theft claims costs: According to a report by IBC, Toronto has the province's highest auto theft claims costs by a large margin. The costs were $397,815,072 in 2023, an increase of 561% from 2018 ($56,223,067).
There are a significant number of collisions: It's estimated there are more than 50,000 accidents per year, which is well over 100 per day.
Inflation: Higher vehicle prices and increasing repair costs are raising the average cost of auto insurance claims.
Insurance fraud: Insurance fraud costs the insurance industry well over $1 billion annually.

Expert car insurance advice for Toronto drivers

I advise all Toronto drivers to maintain a clean driving record and choose a vehicle with excellent safety features to save on car insurance. If you're comfortable with a higher out-of-pocket expense, consider increasing your deductible. Also, don't forget to ask about potential discounts for bundling your insurance policies or installing winter tires. Remember, the best way to find the most affordable rate tailored to your needs is to compare quotes from multiple insurers, which you can easily do through platforms like Thinkinsure.

Wasim Khan

Insurance Broker (RIBO)

Ready to save on your Toronto auto policy?

Monday-Friday: 8am-6pm
Saturday: 9am-5pm

What factors determine how much your Toronto car insurance will cost?

Car insurance prices in Toronto are calculated using many different factors. Your rate can vary significantly based on these considerations and the information you provide. Here are the main factors insurance companies use to calculate rates:

The type of vehicle you drive: Car, SUV, truck, hybrid, van, or compact. The option you choose could increase or decrease your payments. Why? Some are bigger targets for theft. Others have higher repair costs.
Licence class: Your licence type matters - G1, G2, G. You’ll pay less as you progress through the Ontario graduated licence system.
Vehicle use: Do you drive for business or work? Do you drive for Uber or Lyft? Using your vehicle other than for personal purposes will increase your risk and rates.
Your personal profile: Age, gender, and marital status all matter. Generally, more experience and stability make you less of a threat.
Your address: Postal code, neighbourhood, and region impact the chance of you getting in an accident based on claims statistics. Theft, fraud, road conditions, and other threats are assessed by insurers when setting premiums.
Your driving habits: Length of your daily commute and kilometres driven. The more you drive, the greater the risk of a claim.
Coverage: Limits, endorsements, deductible amount, and the number of people on the policy. Try to find a policy that accommodates your protection needs without raising your rates.
Experience behind the wheel: Years licenced, driving record, tickets, fines, and licence suspensions. A few blemishes on your record could spike how much you pay for coverage.
Insurance history: Years insured and previous claims history. Experienced and claims-free drivers will always pay less.
Applicable discounts: Whether or not you qualify for certain discounts. For example age discounts such as for over 50 drivers, alumni or association discounts. For example, age discounts for drivers over 50, alumni, or association discounts.
Secondary drivers: Adding a secondary driver to your policy can significantly impact your rates.

Toronto car insurance FAQs – get answers to commonly asked questions

How do I get cheap monthly car insurance in Toronto?

It’s important to compare car insurance quotes frequently to get cheap rates in Toronto. You should shop around every year.

Your insurance policy is in effect for one calendar year from its renewal date. So, you have an opportunity to compare Toronto car insurance premiums each year. You can see which provider has the best offer for you.

Some years, it may be your existing employer. Other years, it may be another. But you won't know for sure if you don't take the time to compare your options.

But you will only know for sure if you take the time to compare your options.

Who has the cheapest auto insurance in Toronto?

There isn’t a specific insurance company that offers cheaper rates than the rest. It depends on your unique situation.

You won’t know for sure who has the cheapest car insurance unless you compare quotes from multiple providers. For example, you may find that CAA offers you the best rates. However, Aviva or Wawanesa may have more affordable premiums for other drivers.

Why do Toronto auto insurance rates change so often?

Car insurance rates change often for many different reasons. Insurance companies can apply for rate increases quarterly.

The FSRAO reviews and approves the rate increase proposals. They assess current market conditions. A company can request an increase, and it might be approved because of:

The increased cost of claims: Insurers may request an increase because they’ve seen a spike in claims costs.
More collisions on GTA roads: More collisions increase how much insurers have to pay out in claims.
The prevalence of fraud: Fraud and crime rates increase costs for everyone, including drivers.

They can also increase if your driving situation has changed. A ticket, accident, change of address, or even the loss of a discount could affect your rate.

Is having car insurance mandatory to drive in Toronto?

Yes. All drivers across the province must have auto insurance to drive. The fines for driving without insurance are steep. They start at $5,000 and can go up to $25,000 for first-time offenders.

Does adding a G1 or G2 driver affect my car insurance cost?

Adding a G1 driver may not affect your car insurance costs. They cannot be added as the primary driver and can only drive with a parent or experienced driver. If they use your vehicle, you need to notify your insurance company.

Once a G1 driver gets a G2 licence, their rates will increase. They can now drive solo. Young drivers are rated higher as they don't have much experience yet.

Ensure that new or young driver complete a driver education program to help offset the costs of adding them.

When should you check Toronto car insurance rates?

There are plenty of great opportunities to find cheap car insurance in Toronto. While renewal time is the most common, you don't have to wait until you receive your renewal notification to shop around. There are many other good times to check rates:

If you move: Location can greatly impact the threats that exist to you as a driver.
Completion of a driver's training program: You'll qualify for savings upon completion of driving school.
Buying a new vehicle: Purchasing a new vehicle, or changing what you drive affects things like repairs and replacement costs.
When you get married: Social status can affect your rates. Make sure to update it with your insurer.
Your driving record has changed: Is a ticket coming off your record? Tell your provider. They can make sure it does not impact your premium.
You can add or remove a secondary driver from your policy: Adding or removing a driver will alter your costs.
You qualify for new discounts: You can save money by checking rates to see if you qualify for new discounts.

Remember, you don’t need to wait until renewal time to shop around.

Where should I get a car insurance quote in Toronto?

Where you get a car insurance quote will affect your premiums, coverage options, and potential savings. There are three main options for Toronto drivers to get an auto insurance quote:

Direct writers or direct insurers can only offer a single rate from one company.
Comparison sites (aggregators, lead generation sites) offer quotes from multiple providers. However, they sell your information to a third party without direct coverage.
Insurance brokers provide quotes and coverage from many companies. They help you find the best rate and coverage, and then you can buy a policy through them. You also have access to expert advice, knowledge, and customer service.

Therefore, using a broker like ThinkInsure offers you better options, convenience, and savings potential.

What are some Toronto driving tips to help you save on insurance?

You are only a crash or ticket away from more expensive car insurance rates at any given time. Whether you are a seasoned local or a tourist, you need the right policy and driving knowledge.

Here is some helpful advice for navigating the streets and highways safely:

Stay alert: There are many potential dangers on the city's roads. Watch out for pedestrians, cyclists, taxis, and other vehicles.
Avoid rush hour when possible: Before and after work have the most traffic volume. This increases your chances of being in a collision and seeing your rate increase.
Pass streetcars with caution: When streetcars come to a stop, and the doors are open, do not pass. At all stops, allow pedestrians to get on and off.
Watch for cyclists: There are many cyclists and bike lanes. Pay attention when opening car doors. Give one metre when passing a cyclist.
Take extra time when the weather is bad: Driving in poor conditions will take longer.
Expect construction delays: Road construction is ongoing, so be prepared for delays. Check things in advance so you can find the quickest route to your destination.
Know your route: Use a GPS for directions to avoid congestion and arrive at your destination. Also, be aware of alternative routes to save time.
Watch out for one-way streets: There are many one-way streets. Always be conscious of them and consider them when planning your route.
Parking: Expect to pay a lot for parking. Consider using a commuter lot and taking the subway or GO train into town.
Gas up: Fill up on gas before you head downtown. Gas stations are more expensive and less common.

15 tips to get the cheapest car insurance in Toronto

With auto insurance rates being high in Toronto and the GTA area it's important to save as possible. Here are some great tips to help you get the cheapest car insurance in Toronto:

1) Shop and compare

There are many insurance companies in Canada, and their prices change often. Shopping around allows you to compare quotes to see if you are overpaying. Get a quote today and see how much you can save.

2) Combine policies

Combine your home and auto insurance into a single policy. You will automatically qualify for savings of up to 20%. Combining is the best way to save.

3) Review annually

Renewal time is the perfect opportunity to look for new ways to save money. It is also a great time to update your information.

4) Take advantage of discounts

Things change, including the types of car insurance discounts you qualify for. Always ask about available discounts for additional savings.

5) Use winter tires

Winter driving can be challenging and dangerous. By simply using winter tires, you can improve safety, have peace of mind, and save money.

6) Complete driver training

Completing a ministry-approved driver training program will help you obtain a better price. Make sure you tell your insurance company this to save more.

7) Increase your deductible

If you can afford to do so, raise your deductible to lower your rates. The more you increase your deductible, the more you will lower your auto insurance premiums.

8) Good driving behaviour

Keeping your driving record clean is one of the most effective ways to save. Driving safely will save you money now and in the future.

9) Drive a safe vehicle

The type of vehicle you drive matters. Look for vehicles with a strong safety rating, lower repair costs, and security features.

10) Don't miss payments

Missing a payment can affect your rates. If you consistently miss payments, your insurer could cancel your policy. You could save even more by paying in full instead of monthly.

11) Park in a private garage or driveway

If possible, park in a private garage or driveway. This makes your vehicle less likely to get stolen, damaged, or vandalized.

12) Go electric

Some insurers offer a green discount for people who drive hybrid or electric vehicles. Electric car insurance rates depend on the vehicle.

13) Usage based insurance

You can save up to 25% when you use a telematics device to monitor your good driving habits. A number of insurers offer usage-based insurance programs. They include Intact My Drive, CAA MyPace, Aviva Journey, Travelers IntelliDrive, and Pembridge My_BRIDGE.

14) See if you qualify for a group rate

You could save if you belong to a certain group (employer, school, association). Check out your options to see if there are cost-saving opportunities.

15) Add safety devices

Vehicle theft is an issue in Toronto. Adding insurer-approved anti-theft devices can qualify you for savings.

Toronto car insurance companies

A car insurance company doesn’t need to be in Toronto for you to get a quote or coverage. But it doesn’t hurt to have your insurer close by. Some of the best car insurance companies have their head office located in the city. They include:

Aviva - 100 King St. W., Toronto, ON M5X 1E3
CAA Insurance - 106 Spadina Ave., Toronto ON M5V 2K4
Intact - 700 University Ave., Toronto, ON M5G 0A1
Economical - 121 King St. W. #1400, Toronto, ON M5H 3T9
Travelers - 20 Queen St. W., Toronto, ON M5H 3R3
Wawanesa - 4120 Yonge St., Suite 100, North York, ON M2P 2B7
SGI Canada - 10 Four Seasons PI Suite 200, Toronto ON M9B 6H7
Gore Mutual - 320 Bay St, Toronto ON M5H 4A6

ThinkInsure is also located in the city, which is convenient for Toronto drivers and our local insurance company partners. We can assist you in person if needed. We are located at:

5700 Yonge St., Suite 1900
Toronto, ON
M2M 4K2

There are also many more of our partners found across the GTA. ThinkInsure has a big advantage over a direct insurance company. We can help you find the cheapest rates from all the insurance companies listed above and many more.

How driving in Toronto affects auto insurance

Toronto is a very busy city with a lot of traffic, world-class sights to see, and places to go. According to Census data, the GTA is home to some 6.2 million people, with more than 2.7 million residing in Toronto. There are over 2.5 million daily commuters on roadways and public transportation.

The segment of Highway 401 that passes through the city is the busiest highway in North America and one of the widest and busiest in the world. In some sections, AADT (Average Annual Daily Traffic) exceeds 400,000 vehicles.

The city has 9,250 different streets, 160 street intersections, and 2,231 traffic control signals over 5,617 km of streets. Road conditions can change quickly, creating accidents and congestion. All have a big impact on car insurance rates. Greater risk means premiums are more expensive in the city.

Here is some great information about driving in the city.

Major highways

401, 404, 407
QEW
Don Valley Parkway
Gardiner Expressway

Public transit

TTC (Subway, Bus, Streetcar)
Metrolinx GO Transit

Toll roads

407 ETR

Ride-sharing

Uber
Lyft

Road trips

Niagara Falls, Niagara On The Lake
Muskoka cottage country
Bruce Peninsula National Park
Blue Mountain

Parking

City of Toronto Parking
Green P
Impark
Private lots

Top attractions

CN Tower
Royal Ontario Museum (ROM)
Art Gallery of Ontario (AGO))
Ripley's Aquarium Of Canada
Toronto Islands

Busiest intersections

Lake Shore Boulevard East & Lower Sherbourne Street
Finch Avenue West & Norfinch Drive/Oakdale Road
Finch Avenue West & 400 South Finch Westbound Ramp
Finch Avenue West & 400 North Finch Eastbound Ramp
Finch Avenue West & Signet Drive/Arrow Road

Airports

Pearson International Airport
Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport

Car insurance and Toronto driving conditions

Road conditions in Toronto are similar to auto insurance rates in the sense that they vary greatly. Things can change at a moment's notice throughout the year in the city. From hot sunny days to frigid snow-filled roads, you never know what you can expect.

Having good coverage helps manage the unexpected. Checking the forecast and road conditions to prepare for your daily drive is also important.

56 mins

Avg. daily commute time

831 mm

Avg. annual rainfall

121.5 cm

Avg. annual snowfall

114

Rainy days per year

Heat warnings in 2022

Snow days per year

****

Common Toronto car insurance myths

It can be challenging to separate fact from fiction when reading about Toronto car insurance online. Here are some of the most common myths:

Myth 1: Toronto has the most expensive car insurance rates

Toronto does not have the most expensive rates. While it typically appears in the top 5, other cities within the GTA have higher rates.

Myth 2: There are no affordable areas in Toronto for car insurance

Sure, auto insurance is expensive, but this doesn’t mean all areas in the city are the same. Some regions within the city are much more affordable than others.

Myth 3: It's the highway driving that makes auto insurance rates higher

It’s not the highways that increase rates. It's the accidents and traffic volume that contribute to higher premiums.

Myth 4: All Toronto insurance companies charge the same rates

Nope. Insurers rates can vary by hundreds of dollars per year. This is why it’s so important to compare quotes regularly. If you don't, you could be overspending on insurance.

How to file a car insurance claim after an accident in Toronto

Toronto is a city with high accident rates. Drivers need to know what to do if they need to file a car insurance claim. After a collision occurs, you should:

Ensure there are no injuries
Report the accident if there is more than $2,000 in damage.
Contact the police if you suspect illegal activity (fraud, DUI, careless driving)
Move your vehicle to the side of the road if it’s safe to do so
Exchange insurance and vehicle information with the other driver
Take photos to document the damage
Visit the reporting centre in the area where the accident occurred. There are more than 30 reporting centers in the GTA.
Call for a tow truck if required to take your vehicle to the reporting centre
Call your advisor or insurer to start the claims process

If you are an existing ThinkInsure customer, you can use our claims services for assistance.

Finding the best Toronto car insurance rates is easy!

With ThinkInsure, you can compare quotes online from our large selection of auto insurance companies in Toronto and save money. You'll be able to find the best rates in just a couple of minutes.

You can save even more by speaking with one of our advisors. They'll make sure you obtain proper coverage while ensuring you save as much as possible.

Get Started

Sources

* Based on the difference between the average lowest premium and the overall average premium in Toronto for estimates completed from January 1 to March 20, 2025, for drivers with a clean driving record.

** Estimated premiums are based on data entered by individuals on ThinkInsure.ca from 2020-2025.

*** Estimated premiums are based on data entered by people on ThinkInsure.ca from January 1, 2025, to March 20, 2025.

**** ThinkInsure customer quoter data from January 1 to August 15, 2024. Drivers with a G licence, clean driving record, and standard coverage.

***** Geography of Toronto

Nolan Wilson

Content Marketing Manager

Nolan is a content marketing manager and writer at ThinkInsure. He has 15+ years of experience in the insurance industry, working with brokerages and direct insurers to create compelling insurance content, specializing in auto, home, and commercial.

Insurance Blog And News

Read our insurance blog to get helpful tips, information and news.

Poeple looking at insurane documents for non-payment options

2025-05-30

Compare Cheap Toronto Car Insurance Quotes